Acadia National Park vs Great Smoky Mountains: Which Park is Better?
The Traveling Elms contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Affiliate Program. If you make purchases using one of these links, I may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. Read my disclaimer for more information.
Are you struggling to choose between Acadia National Park vs. Great Smoky Mountains National Park?
We can help!
We’ve spent quite a bit of time in both of these national parks, so we can help you understand the differences so you can decide which is the right park for you. Both parks boast natural beauty and plenty of outdoor adventures, but the experiences they offer are quite different.
Acadia National Park is known for its rugged coastline, granite peaks, and scenic drives along the Atlantic. It’s a paradise for hikers, with trails that offer stunning ocean views and challenging climbs. Visitors also enjoy exploring lakes, carriage roads, and the charming town of Bar Harbor.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park, on the other hand, is famous for its rolling mist-covered mountains, lush forests, and diverse wildlife. Nature lovers come for the range of trails, waterfalls, and historical cabins nestled deep in the woods. The park is on the border of North Carolina and Tennessee, making it accessible for visitors from both states.
In this post, we’ll compare the key similarities and differences between Acadia National Park and Great Smoky Mountains National Park, including the costs, weather, landscapes, wildlife, and activities available in each park.
OUR FAVORITE CAMPING RESOURCES
Getting Mail: Escapees
Roadschooling Classes: Outschool
Route Planning & RV GPS: RV Life
Unique camping stays: Harvest Hosts
Find other families on the road: Full-Time Families
Camp all year for $670: Thousand Trails Membership
Snag Reservations at Sold Out Campgrounds: CampNab
Acadia National Park vs Great Smoky Mountains National Park: Which Park is Better?
It’s hard to say which is better; Acadia National Park or Great Smoky Mountains National Park Bora. That’s because it depends on who you ask and their idea of what they like in a National Park.
If you prefer having access to high-quality dining and amenities while enjoying scenic coastal views, then you’ll probably prefer a visit to Acadia National Park.
But if you’re seeking a more rugged adventure, love a wide variety of outdoor activities, or are working with a tighter travel budget, Great Smoky Mountains National Park is the way to go.
Key Differences Between Acadia National Park vs. Great Smoky Mountains National Park
Let’s get deeper into the main differences between Acadia National Park and Great Smoky Mountains National Park, so you can get a clearer picture of what to expect from each national park before deciding where to go!
Costs & Prices
Acadia National Park:
- Entrance fee: $35 per vehicle for a 7-day pass.
- Lodging: Expect higher prices, especially in nearby Bar Harbor. Hotel rates range from $150 to $400+ per night during peak season.
- Dining: Local seafood and fine dining can be pricey. Expect to pay a premium for the area’s specialty dishes like lobster rolls.
- Pro Tip: Many activities, like hiking and biking the historic carriage roads, are free, but plan for extras like boat tours or ranger-led programs.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park:
- No entrance fee, making it a budget-friendly option.
- Lodging: Hotels in Gatlinburg or Pigeon Forge are generally more affordable, starting around $100 per night.
- Dining: Family-friendly and casual restaurants dominate the area, offering plenty of options that won’t break the bank.
- Money Saver: Most attractions, like hiking trails and scenic drives, are free, with affordable extras like Cades Cove Loop and historic site visits.
Best Time to Visit
Acadia National Park:
- Peak Season: Summer (June to August) for warm weather and clear skies.
- Shoulder Season: Late spring and early fall. You’ll enjoy cooler temperatures, vibrant fall foliage, and fewer crowds—perfect for scenic hiking and biking.
- Winter: Acadia becomes a winter wonderland but requires careful planning due to limited accessibility.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park:
- Best Seasons: Fall for its spectacular foliage, spring for wildflowers, and summer for lush green views.
- Winter and Early Spring: Quieter and budget-friendly, but some higher elevation trails may be snow-covered or icy.
- Insider Tip: October weekends can get crowded with leaf-peepers, so aim for weekday visits for a more peaceful experience.
Landscapes
Acadia National Park:
- Rugged coastal beauty with rocky shorelines, dense forests, and granite peaks.
- Cadillac Mountain: The highest point on the U.S. East Coast, perfect for sunrise enthusiasts.
- Pristine lakes and 45 miles of historic carriage roads for hiking and biking.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park:
- Famous for mist-covered mountains, lush, old-growth forests, and cascading waterfalls.
- More than 800 miles of trails, including sections of the Appalachian Trail.
- Scenic Drives: Routes like Cades Cove Loop offer a chance to see historic cabins and abundant wildlife.
Wildlife
Acadia National Park:
- Spot white-tailed deer, porcupines, and red foxes. Birdwatchers might see peregrine falcons or seabirds like puffins.
- Marine Life: Harbor seals and occasional whale sightings add to the appeal.
- Birding Tip: Visit during migration seasons for a greater variety of seabird species.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park:
- Known for its thriving black bear population and the nickname “Salamander Capital of the World.”
- Look for elk in the Cataloochee Valley, white-tailed deer, wild turkeys, and over 200 species of birds.
- Safety Reminder: Always follow park guidelines for bear safety, especially if you’re camping or hiking.
Things to Do
Acadia National Park:
- Top Activities: Hike trails like Precipice or Jordan Pond Path, drive the Park Loop Road, or bike the carriage roads.
- Water lovers can kayak or go sailing, while stargazers will enjoy the park’s astoundingly dark skies.
- Local Tip: Bar Harbor is a must-visit for quaint shops, seafood restaurants, and boat tours.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park:
- Over 800 miles of trails await, from easy waterfall hikes to strenuous mountain climbs.
- Don’t miss scenic auto tours like Newfound Gap Road and Cades Cove for history and wildlife viewing.
- Family-friendly activities include horseback riding, fishing, and exploring Gatlinburg’s attractions like Ripley’s Aquarium and Dollywood.
Getting Around
Acadia National Park:
- Easy to navigate, with a free Island Explorer shuttle (late June to mid-October) to help avoid parking woes.
- The Park Loop Road is a great way to hit the main attractions, but be prepared for crowds during peak times.
- Biking is popular on the car-free carriage roads, perfect for a leisurely day.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park:
- Much larger and more spread out, so a car is essential. No public transportation within the park.
- Traffic Alert: Expect congestion on popular roads, especially during fall.
- Scenic drives like Roaring Fork Motor Nature Trail offer a peaceful alternative to busier areas.
Bar Harbor vs. Gatlinburg / Pigeon Forge
Bar Harbor (Acadia):
Bar Harbor is a charming coastal town with a laid-back, small-town feel. It’s known for its beautiful waterfront, quaint streets, and local shops. The town offers a range of seafood restaurants, art galleries, and boutique stores, making it a perfect spot for a relaxing evening after exploring Acadia.
The vibe in Bar Harbor is more peaceful, with an emphasis on nature and scenic beauty. It’s also the gateway to boat tours, whale watching, and other coastal activities. If you enjoy a quieter, more picturesque setting with a focus on nature, Bar Harbor is an excellent choice.
Best For: Nature lovers seeking a peaceful atmosphere and easy access to Acadia’s adventures.
Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge (Smokies):
Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge offer a more vibrant, entertainment-focused experience. These towns are bustling with attractions, from amusement parks like Dollywood in Pigeon Forge to the Ripley’s Aquarium and various museums in Gatlinburg. Both towns are filled with restaurants, shops, and family-friendly activities.
Pigeon Forge, in particular, is known for its lively atmosphere with theaters, dinner shows, and endless entertainment options. Gatlinburg, while also busy, has a more walkable downtown area with a mix of touristy attractions and access to the Smokies’ hiking trails. If you’re looking for a lively, action-packed experience with plenty of activities for all ages, Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge are ideal.
Best For: Families and adventure seekers who want a mix of nature and entertainment.
Acadia National Park vs Great Smoky Mountains National Park: Where to Stay (for RVer’s)
Acadia National Park and Great Smoky Mountains National Park both offer excellent options for RVers, but the experiences and amenities differ based on the park’s location and surrounding areas.
Best Places to Stay Near Acadia National Park
Acadia has several campgrounds suitable for RVs, with Blackwoods Campground being the most popular within the park. However, Blackwoods doesn’t offer hookups, so it’s more suited for self-sufficient RVers. Seawall Campground is another option, also without hookups but offering a more peaceful, less crowded experience.
Outside the park, there are private campgrounds in nearby Bar Harbor with full hookups, such as Narrows Too and Bar Harbor Campground. These campgrounds are close enough to explore the park while enjoying Bar Harbor restaurants, shops, and grocery stores.
Best Places to Stay Near Great Smoky Mountains National Park
The Smokies provide a wide range of options for RVers, with campgrounds both inside and outside the park. Within the park, Cades Cove and Elkmont Campgrounds are popular among RVers, but they don’t offer hookups. These campgrounds are surrounded by nature, offering a more rustic experience.
If you prefer full hookups, there are several private campgrounds just outside the park, particularly in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge. Options like Twin Creek RV Resort and Smoky Bear Campground offer full amenities, plus easy access to the park’s entrances.
Acadia National Park vs Great Smoky Mountains National Park: How Many Days?
Deciding how many days to spend in Acadia National Park versus Great Smoky Mountains National Park depends on what you want to see and do in each park.
How Many Days in Acadia National Park
You can get a really great experience at Acadia in 2 to 3 days. This time frame allows you to drive the Park Loop Road, hike popular trails like Cadillac Mountain or Jordan Pond, explore Bar Harbor, and take part in activities like biking the carriage roads or kayaking.
If you want to dive deeper into more trails, explore the Schoodic Peninsula, or spend time on the water, 4 to 5 days would be ideal.
How Many Days in Great Smoky Mountains National Park
Due to the park’s larger size and variety of attractions, 3 to 5 days is a good starting point. This will give you time to explore key areas like Cades Cove, Clingmans Dome, and some of the park’s famous waterfalls.
If you’re into hiking, you might want to spend more time tackling a few of the longer trails, such as a section of the Appalachian Trail. Additionally, the nearby attractions in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge could easily add a day or two to your trip, especially if you want to experience Dollywood or some of the local museums and shows.
Acadia National Park vs Great Smoky Mountains National Park: Which is Better With Kids?
When deciding between Acadia National Park and Great Smoky Mountains National Park for a family trip, both parks offer fantastic experiences, but they cater to different types of family adventures.
Acadia is better for families looking for a quieter, nature-focused trip with easy hikes and scenic beauty, while Great Smoky Mountains offers a broader range of activities, making it a better fit for families who want both outdoor experiences and entertainment options for kids of all ages.
Acadia National Park for Kids
Acadia is a great destination for families who love the outdoors and want to introduce their kids to nature in a more serene setting. The park has a variety of family-friendly activities, including easy hikes like the Ocean Path or Jordan Pond Path, which offer stunning views without being too strenuous.
Kids will love exploring the tide pools at low tide and biking along the car-free carriage roads. Bar Harbor offers a quaint, walkable town with plenty of family-friendly restaurants and shops. However, Acadia’s quieter atmosphere may be better suited for families with older kids who enjoy hiking, nature, and less crowded environments.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park for Kids
The Smokies are ideal for families with kids of all ages, especially if you’re looking for a mix of nature and entertainment. The park offers a wide range of kid-friendly activities, including easy hikes to waterfalls, scenic drives like Cades Cove where you can spot wildlife, and historical sites like old cabins and mills.
Beyond the park, Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge provide endless entertainment options, from amusement parks like Dollywood to interactive museums, aquariums, and live shows. This makes the Smokies a perfect choice for families who want a balance of outdoor adventure and lively, kid-focused attractions.
Acadia National Park vs Great Smoky Mountains National Park: Which is Better for Dogs?
Both Acadia National Park and Great Smoky Mountains National Park are dog-friendly, but they have different rules and amenities for visitors traveling with their furry friends.
Acadia National Park is the better choice if you want to enjoy hiking and outdoor activities with your dog, as it offers more freedom and accessibility for pets. Great Smoky Mountains National Park is more limited for dog owners, with only a couple of trails available, making it less ideal for those looking to explore the park with their dogs.
Acadia National Park With Dogs
Acadia is one of the most dog-friendly national parks in the U.S. Dogs are allowed on nearly all 100 miles of the park’s hiking trails and on the 45 miles of carriage roads, making it a great destination if you want to explore with your dog by your side.
Pets are also welcome at campgrounds and on the Park Loop Road, but they must be on a leash no longer than six feet. Bar Harbor, the nearby town, is also dog-friendly, with many restaurants offering outdoor seating where dogs are welcome. However, dogs are not allowed on beaches and certain trails that require climbing.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park With Dogs
The Smoky Mountains are less accommodating for dogs. While pets are allowed in campgrounds, picnic areas, and along roads, they are restricted to only two short walking paths—the Gatlinburg Trail and the Oconaluftee River Trail.
Dogs are not allowed on any of the park’s other hiking trails due to concerns about wildlife and the safety of both pets and park visitors. Outside the park, Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge offer more dog-friendly options, including some pet-friendly accommodations and outdoor dining spots.
FAQ: Acadia National Park vs Great Smoky Mountains
What’s so special about Acadia National Park?
Acadia National Park is special for its stunning mix of coastal and mountain scenery, including dramatic cliffs and Cadillac Mountain, the tallest peak on the East Coast. The park offers diverse activities like hiking, biking its scenic carriage roads, and wildlife viewing, including seabirds and harbor seals.
Bar Harbor, a charming nearby town, adds to the appeal, and the park’s dark skies make it great for stargazing. It’s a year-round destination with beautiful fall foliage, winter activities, and fewer crowds in spring. This blend of natural beauty and outdoor adventures makes Acadia unique.
What’s so special about Great Smoky Mountains National Park?
Great Smoky Mountains National Park is special for its incredible biodiversity, mist-covered mountains, and expansive old-growth forests. It’s one of the few national parks with no entrance fee, making it accessible to everyone.
The park is home to a large population of black bears, over 800 miles of hiking trails, and scenic drives like Cades Cove, where you can spot wildlife and historic cabins. It’s famous for its stunning fall foliage, spring wildflowers, and being part of the Appalachian Trail. The Smokies’ mix of natural beauty, wildlife, and cultural history makes it a top destination.
Is Acadia National Park worth seeing?
Yes, Acadia National Park is definitely worth seeing. Its unique combination of rugged coastline, mountain views, and diverse wildlife offers something for every outdoor enthusiast. Whether you want to hike, bike scenic carriage roads, or watch the sunrise from Cadillac Mountain, Acadia provides breathtaking landscapes and activities.
The park’s proximity to the charming town of Bar Harbor adds to the experience with great dining and local culture. If you love nature and coastal beauty, Acadia is a must-see destination.
Is Great Smoky Mountains National Park worth visiting?
Yes, Great Smoky Mountains National Park is absolutely worth visiting. It’s known for its stunning mountain views, rich biodiversity, and beautiful hiking trails. The park offers a range of experiences, from wildlife viewing (including black bears) to exploring waterfalls and scenic drives like Cades Cove.
With no entrance fee and a variety of activities, including family-friendly attractions in nearby Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge, the Smokies are perfect for nature lovers and those looking for an affordable adventure. The park’s famous fall foliage and spring wildflowers make it a top destination year-round.
Can you smoke in Acadia National Park?
Smoking is allowed in Acadia National Park, but there are restrictions. You cannot smoke in certain areas like visitor centers, ranger stations, restrooms, or on hiking trails. Additionally, smoking is prohibited in any location where it could pose a fire hazard or disturb the natural environment.
It’s always a good idea to check for any specific park regulations or fire bans before lighting up. Be mindful to dispose of cigarette butts properly to protect the park’s natural beauty.
Can you smoke in Great Smoky Mountains National Park?
Smoking is allowed in Great Smoky Mountains National Park, but there are restrictions similar to other national parks. Smoking is prohibited inside buildings, such as visitor centers and restrooms, and on most hiking trails due to fire risk and environmental concerns.
Additionally, smoking is not allowed in areas where it could pose a safety hazard or disturb wildlife. Always make sure to properly dispose of cigarette butts and check for any fire bans or specific park regulations before smoking.
How many mountains are in Acadia National Park?
Acadia National Park is home to 26 mountains. The tallest and most famous is Cadillac Mountain, which, at 1,530 feet, is the highest point on the U.S. East Coast. Other notable peaks include Dorr Mountain, Sargent Mountain, and Penobscot Mountain. These mountains offer a variety of hiking trails and stunning views of the park’s rugged coastline, forests, and lakes.
How many mountains are in Great Smoky Mountains National Park?
Great Smoky Mountains National Park contains over 16 mountain peaks that reach elevations above 5,000 feet. The highest peak is Clingmans Dome, which stands at 6,643 feet and is the highest point in the park as well as the third-highest peak east of the Mississippi River.
Other notable peaks include Mount LeConte and Mount Guyot. The park is part of the larger Appalachian Mountain range and is famous for its rolling, mist-covered mountains and lush forests.
Is Acadia National Park safe?
Yes, Acadia National Park is generally safe for visitors, but like any outdoor destination, it’s important to take precautions. The park’s rugged terrain, including steep cliffs and rocky trails, can pose risks, so it’s crucial to follow marked trails and be mindful of weather conditions.
Tides can also change quickly along the coastline, so it’s important to check tide schedules, especially if exploring tidal areas. Wildlife encounters are rare but possible, so maintaining a safe distance from animals is advised. Overall, as long as you stay aware of your surroundings, follow park guidelines, and come prepared, Acadia is a safe and enjoyable place to visit.
Is Great Smoky Mountains National Park safe?
Yes, Great Smoky Mountains National Park is generally safe for visitors, but there are some precautions to keep in mind. The park’s vast wilderness includes uneven terrain, steep trails, and changing weather conditions, so it’s important to stay on marked trails and be prepared with proper gear. Black bears are common in the park, so following park guidelines on bear safety—like storing food properly and keeping a safe distance—is essential.
The park also has heavy traffic in some areas, especially near popular spots like Cades Cove, so be cautious when driving. As long as you stay informed, follow park rules, and come prepared, the Smokies are a safe and rewarding destination.
How busy is Acadia National Park?
Acadia National Park can get quite busy, especially during the peak season from June to October. Summer months and early fall, particularly when the foliage changes, attract the most visitors. Popular areas like Cadillac Mountain, Jordan Pond, and Sand Beach often see high foot traffic, and parking can be challenging.
Early mornings or weekdays can offer a more peaceful experience, even during peak times. To avoid the crowds, consider visiting in the off-season, such as late spring or late fall, when the park is quieter but still beautiful. The free Island Explorer shuttle, available during the summer, can also help you navigate the park without the hassle of parking.
How busy is Great Smoky Mountains National Park?
Great Smoky Mountains National Park is the most visited national park in the U.S., so it can get very busy, especially during peak seasons. The busiest times are in the summer, during fall foliage (October), and on weekends.
Popular areas like Cades Cove, Clingmans Dome, and Newfound Gap can see heavy traffic and crowded trails, particularly in the fall when leaf-peeping is at its peak.
To avoid crowds, visit during weekdays, early in the morning, or in the off-seasons like winter or late spring. The park is vast, so exploring less-known trails and areas can also offer a more peaceful experience, even during busy times.
Acadia National Park vs Great Smoky Mountains National Park: Which is Better to Visit?
Choosing between Acadia National Park and Great Smoky Mountains National Park depends on your preferences and the type of adventure you’re looking for.
Acadia National Park is ideal if you’re drawn to dramatic coastal scenery, enjoy hiking with ocean views, and prefer a quieter, more intimate experience. It’s especially appealing for those who love outdoor activities like biking, kayaking, and exploring a quaint, nearby town like Bar Harbor. If you’re traveling with a dog or want a more dog-friendly environment, Acadia is the better option.
Great Smoky Mountains National Park, on the other hand, is perfect if you’re looking for a vast, diverse landscape with rolling mountains, lush forests, and abundant wildlife. It’s an excellent choice for families with kids or those who want a mix of outdoor activities and entertainment. The proximity to Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge adds a level of excitement and variety, making it an ideal destination for those who enjoy both nature and lively attractions.
In summary, Acadia is better for those seeking coastal beauty, serene hikes, and dog-friendly adventures, while Great Smoky Mountains is better for families, those who enjoy a range of activities, and anyone looking for a mix of natural and entertainment-focused experiences. Both parks offer incredible experiences, so the “better” park really depends on what kind of adventure you’re after.
Looking for more travel tips?
We love to share about our favorite destinations! Read more about whether Acadia National Park is worth it, things to do in Acadia when it rains, Bar Harbor, our favorite things to do in Kentucky, Top Cincinnati attractions, kid-friendly activities in Santa Rosa Beach, and how to spend Christmas in Florida.
For our favorite places to stay, check out our campground page where you can learn more about the top camping memberships, including Passport America and Thousand Trails.
